Hot stud Silas O'Hara was caught stealing a dildo at a local sex shop, and the guys are just getting started with him. Silas is bound in the middle of the store with a gag in his mouth as everyone comes up rubbing all over his body. Everyone says Silas' skin isn't red enough so they break out the flogger and beat the stud from front to back. Once he's nice and red they torment Silas' cock and balls with the zapper before having him crawl to the back arcade. Jay Cloud is waiting with his big fat cock for the stud to come service cock. Everyone takes turns shoving their cocks through the glory hole as Jay shoves Silas' head down on every cock. The guys take turns fucking his ass left and right before blasting him in the face with cum. They let Silas blow his load and shove his head to the floor for him to lick it all up. Before they let the little thief go they hold him down and hose him off as they take turns pissing on him.